On a Wednesday night in April 2023, Robert Dotson — a 52-year-old father of two — heard knocking at his front door in Farmington, New Mexico just before midnight. He put on a robe, walked downstairs, picked up his legally owned handgun, and answered the door on his own property. Three police officers were standing outside, shining a flashlight in his face. They shot and killed him. The officers had been dispatched to a domestic violence call at 5308 Valley View Avenue. They went to 5305 — the house directly across the street. One officer had used his patrol car's GPS and placed the address on the wrong side of the street. A second officer had searched Google Maps, which correctly showed the house on the opposite side — and that officer verbally questioned whether they were at the right address before the knock anyway. They proceeded. When Dotson appeared at his door holding a firearm, blinded by flashlights, with no reason to believe the people outside were police, he raised the gun. The officers opened fire. He did not shoot. His wife then emerged, fired at the unknown figures outside, and only stopped when she realized they were officers. She was not told her husband was dead for eight hours. The officers did not immediately disclose to investigators that they had been at the wrong address — that detail was discovered by other officers who arrived on scene. No criminal charges were filed against the officers. When Dotson's family sued for civil rights violations, a federal judge dismissed the case in May 2025, ruling that the officers had acted reasonably given the circumstances — circumstances entirely of their own creation.
| Tony Webster / tony@tonywebster.com |
Commentary: A man answered his own front door with a legal firearm, got killed by police who had been told they were at the wrong address and went anyway, and a federal judge decided that's just how the Constitution works. The legal term for this is "qualified immunity." The plain English term is getting away with it.
⚠️ This content was researched and written with AI assistance and may be fully AI-generated. All facts are sourced from the linked NBC News article and corroborating reporting from ABC News, CBS News, and Reason.