Not every government abuse is big government and the Feds:
Brookside, Alabama has 1,253 residents and sits along Interstate 22 just northwest of Birmingham. In 2018 the town discovered something more reliable than tax revenue: drivers. Beginning that year, Brookside's police department systematically transformed itself from a public safety operation into a revenue extraction machine, increasing ticket and fine income by 640% in just two years. At the height of the scheme, fines, fees, and forfeitures made up more than 50% of the town's entire general fund — and 89 cents of every dollar collected went straight back to the police department, which used it to buy unmarked black SUVs, military-style equipment, and a mine-resistant armored vehicle that officers parked outside the police station. Arrests skyrocketed 1,100% as officers fanned out along the interstate looking for anyone to pull over. When a car was towed — which happened routinely, even when vehicles were perfectly drivable — the driver owed $175 to Brookside before they could even begin paying the private towing company's fees and daily impound charges. Brittany Coleman was pulled over, handcuffed for 30 minutes, had her car searched for marijuana, passed three field sobriety tests, and was still charged with marijuana possession and had her car towed anyway. No marijuana was found. Chekeithia Grant arrived at the scene of her daughter's traffic stop to help, and both women were arrested and jailed on misdemeanor charges while their cars were towed — destroying a 60th birthday party they had been driving to. The U.S. Department of Justice eventually intervened. In February 2026, Brookside agreed to a $1.5 million class action settlement, is banned from collecting policing revenue for five years, and was required to issue a formal written acknowledgment that its aggressive policing scheme "likely interfered with the Town's obligation to administer justice equally under law" and raised serious constitutional concerns. The police chief resigned. Alabama passed new legislation aimed at curbing small-town ticketing abuse. The armored vehicle presumably remains.
| S.MacMillen - public domain |
Commentary: A town of 1,253 people bought a mine-resistant military vehicle with speeding ticket money while arresting people 1,100% more often than before — and called it keeping the public safe. Brittany Coleman passed every test they gave her and they towed her car anyway, because the car was worth more to Brookside's budget than her constitutional rights were. "Police are supposed to protect and serve, not ticket and collect," she said after the settlement. She shouldn't have had to say it.
⚠️ This content was researched and written with AI assistance and may be fully AI-generated. All facts are sourced from the linked Courthouse News and Institute for Justice articles, and corroborating reporting from ABC 33/40, Alabama Reporter, and Birmingham Free Press.